Sometimes Soundbite Financial Advice Can Be Problematic

Whether from traditional financial advisors or from radio show talking heads, you will hear financial advice spouted as clichés over and over. These sayings sound logical, but they often sacrifice financial judgment for the sake of brief dictums that are trite but easily grasped if not actually accurate. Financial clichés can cause long-term problems and put some households decades behind others in similar situations that make better financial choices.

What are some cliches about money that are not true?

Cliches that instruct an individual or a couple to sacrifice their long-term goals for the sake of short-sighted objectives can cause more troubles than they help to resolve. Those that focus solely on one household’s financial aspect at the expense of others will often lead to more problems.

Because these cliches sometimes come from professionals with certifications or licenses (e.g. CPAs, financial advisors, financial counselors), too many consumers accept them at face value. Consider the four money cliches below, why they are so popular (the justification), how they can harm your household finances (the problem), and what you can do instead (the alternative).

Pay Off Your Debt Before Saving or Investing

This money cliché has been around for generations. You are most likely to hear it from behind the desk at a CPA’s office or from your financial advisor. Too many consumers assume that if such highly qualified advisors give such advice, it must be true. However, most households will be better off adjusting the cliches for their own unique circumstances and personalities.

The Justification for Paying off Debt before Saving or Investing

Because the interest rates you pay on debts are almost always higher than anything you could earn on money in a savings or investment account, some advisors tell all their clients to pay off their debts first. Later, when the consumers are out of debt, they will receive advice to start saving and investing.

The Problem with Delaying Savings and Investing until After Paying off Debts

All three of these activities are more than numbers. Paying off debt, saving for emergencies, and investing for the future all involve commitments, habits, and mindsets. If you wait to start one activity until after you have finished another, your chances of starting at all can be pretty low.

The Alternative to Delaying Your Savings and Investments until Paying Off Debts

Most households should consider committing to all three activities simultaneously, even if not all equally. While repaying debts should rightly be prioritized, it should not be at the cost of all saving and investing activities.

Let’s say you have $400 available to use after your living expenses and other important bills. This cliché would have you send all $400 to your debts and contribute nothing to savings or investment accounts.

Alternatively, committing to do all three right from the start might look something like this: focus 80% of your disposable cash ($320) on accelerating your debt repayment while using 10% to build savings ($40) and another 10% to invest for your future ($40).

That way, once you pay off all your debt, you are already in the habit of saving and can simply transfer your debt payment to your emergency savings and investment accounts. At that point, you would be sending $200 to savings and $200 to investments. Once your savings balance reaches an acceptable level, you can then transfer the entire $400 to your investments.

Never Pay off Your Mortgage

Homeowners will hear this cliché from their financial advisor, perhaps a CPA, and even their mortgage officer.

The Justification for Never Paying off Your Mortgage

The current tax laws offer definite advantages to homeowners with a mortgage. Though overly simplistic, the law says homeowners can deduct the amount of interest from their taxable income, lowering the amount of tax they pay throughout the term of the loan. These tax savings are not insignificant.

Consequently, advisors will often tell homeowners that the tax benefits of carrying a mortgage are worth more than anything the homeowner could earn through a savings account, on Wall Street, or with other investments.

The Problem with Never Paying off Your Mortgage

Not everything about homeownership is related to a balance sheet. The Great Recession should have taught homeowners that financial freedom is more than just tax deductions and write-offs.

Paying off your mortgage means you can experience greater financial freedom. No lender has any claim on your home.

During recessions and pandemics (or anytime, really), it doesn’t matter how long you’ve been making your mortgage payments on time because all it takes are a few months of missed payments due to job loss or medical emergencies to see your home foreclosed.

Yes, you might think you could refinance, but what lender wants to refinance a loan for a borrower without any sort of steady income? Plus, if the household market has dipped as it did during the great recession, you may not be able to refinance even with a steady income if your home’s value has dropped below the balance on your mortgage.

The Alternative to Never Paying off Your Mortgage

First of all, make sure you are aware of your housing options should you lose your income. Consider the worst-case scenario of trying to sell your home in a down market. With a mortgage but no income, you could lose your home. Granted, the government has instituted several programs and protections for homebuyers using a government-guaranteed mortgage, but even they have their limits.

On the other hand, the only thing homeowners without a mortgage have to pay during such times is property tax and insurance premiums, and those are usually annually or possibly quarterly. However, many taxing authorities first move toward a lien on the property for back taxes rather than foreclosure.

Always Borrow to Buy a Vehicle if the APR Is Less than Inflation

This cliché usually originates with a financial advisor or perhaps a CPA. On paper, the recommendation to buy your vehicles with borrowed money at low-interest rates makes sense. As with most clichés, though, this one fails to consider long-term and individual issues.

The Justification for Borrowing to Purchase a Vehicle

The math for this cliché advice is straightforward enough. If you’re paying on a loan whose APR is lower than inflation, then it’s like the lender is paying you the difference between your APR and inflation. Why wouldn’t you borrow money for a vehicle in such cases?

The Problem with Borrowing to Buy a Vehicle

First, inflation can change, and it can change quickly. A low-interest rate today can seem like an intolerable rate in six months if inflation dropped to near 0%. In times of deflation, the APR would seem even more onerous.

Worst and more common, though, is the reality that for the first half of most car loans, the borrower is upside-down on their loan. That means that since the vehicle loses an extraordinary amount of its value during the first two years or so after manufacture, the borrower will owe more money than the vehicle is worth.

Many also describe these situations as the borrower being underwater. If the borrower has enough funds in saving to repay the balance of the loan if necessary, then this becomes less of an issue. Otherwise, it just takes the loss or reduction of income to create hardship in the home when it comes to the vehicle.

Unlike homeowners, car and truck owners have no government programs and virtually no nonprofit agencies to turn to for help when they get behind on their vehicle loan payments. And since the borrower owes more than the value of the vehicle, no one will purchase the car. Just as few (no one) will be interested in assuming the loan either, presuming it can be taken over by another consumer in the first place.

That leaves the borrower with two unpleasant and equally damaging options when it comes to their vehicle: first, they could voluntarily surrender the vehicle to the lender, and second, they can wait until the lender repossesses the vehicle.

While a voluntary repossession will save the borrower from being charged multiple fees related to repossession, both options have the same negative effect on the borrower’s credit.

The Alternative to Borrowing to Buy a Vehicle

Such a trend may be unlikely to happen, but as more consumers see their vehicles as something that gets them from Point A to Point B rather than as a symbol of their success and status, we would see far fewer consumers underwater in vehicles too expensive for their household finances. Safety concerns for parents and fuel efficiency can be considerations, but with the average new car payment somewhere between $600 and $700 a month, maybe it’s time to consider simplifying your own transportation requirements.

Besides purchasing lower-priced vehicles, putting larger down payments on the vehicle or purchasing 100% in cash will reduce or eliminate consumer issues related to being upside down on their car loans.

Never Use Credit Cards

This cliché is probably the newest of those listed in this post. If not originating with popular talking heads on the radio and online, this cliché has certainly received a boost from these talk show hosts, spreading it far and wide. It plays on consumer fears based on past experiences or horror stories of other consumers.

The Justification for Never Using Credit Cards

Here’s how the story goes. It’s so easy to get into overwhelming credit card debt, and credit card companies are so evil and greedy that consumers should just never use these products.

The Problem with Never Using Credit Cards

As with any decision based on fear, this advice misses the mark. It’s reactionary advice against the symptom, but it ignores the cause.

This advice is a knee-jerk reaction based on fear, not on reality. If you ever want to borrow money to purchase a home, you’re going to need a mortgage. And that mortgage lender will give you better repayment terms if you’ve used credit wisely (not going into debt) for years.

Instead of helping consumers to develop the discipline and the surrounding spending systems that make credit card debt much less likely, this cliché jumps past the cause of credit card debt and greatly hinders the consumer’s credit-building opportunities.

The Alternative to Never Using Credit Cards

We often suggest that consumers who have no credit history or who have struggled with credit card debt in the past start small and even start local. A store card from a local or regional clothing store in the mall might offer not only a 10% to 15% discount on what you were going to buy anyway, but if you stop at the customer service desk before exiting and pay off the entire balance you won’t have to pay any interest or worry about your balance getting out of control. Congratulations, you just used credit wisely.

You can also do this with a standard credit card except that instead of stopping at the customer service desk, you make the payment to the credit card account through the credit card company’s phone app or online payment portal.

For additional alternatives, see our Complete How-To Guide to Building Credit.

About the Author

This Website Is Using Cookies. We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our cookie use.

Client Credit Report Authorization

You hereby authorize and instruct Debt Reduction Services, Inc. (DRS, dba Money Fit by DRS) and/or its assigned agents to:
  • Obtain and review your credit report, and
  • Request verifications of your income and rental history, and any other information deemed necessary for improving your housing situation (for example, verifying your annual property tax obligations and homeowner’s insurance fees)
Your credit report will be obtained from a credit reporting agency chosen by DRS. You understand and agree that DRS intends to use the credit report evaluate your financial readiness to purchase or rent a home and/or to engage in post-purchase counseling activities and not to grant credit. You understand you may ask any questions pertaining to your credit report. However, while DRS will review the information with you, the company is not able to furnish you with a copy of your credit profile. You hereby authorize DRS to share your information from your credit report and any information that you provided (including any computations and assessments produced) with the entities listed below to help DRS determine your viable financial options.
  • Banks
  • Counseling Agencies
  • Debt Collectors
  • Landlords
  • Lenders
  • Mortgage Servicers
  • Property Management Companies
  • Public Housing Authorities
  • Social Service Agencies
Entities such as mortgage lenders and/or counseling agencies may contact your DRS counselor to evaluate the options for which you may be eligible. In connection with such evaluation, you authorize the credit reporting and/or financial agencies to release information and cooperate with your DRS counselor. No information will be discussed about you with entities not directly involved in your efforts to improve your housing situation. You hereby authorize the release of your information to program monitoring organizations of DRS, including but not limited to, Federal, State, and nonprofit partners for program review, monitoring, auditing, research, and/or oversight purposes. In addition, you authorize DRS to have your credit report pulled two additional times to conduct program evaluations. You also agree to keep DRS informed of any changes in address, telephone number, job status, marital status, or other conditions which may affect your eligibility for a program you have applied for or a counseling service that you are seeking. Finally, you understand that you may revoke consent to these disclosures by notifying DRS in writing.

Client Privacy, Data Security, and Client Rights Policy

NOTE: This sheet is to inform new or returning clients about our services, records, fees, and limitations that may affect you as a consumer of our services. This form also discloses how we might release your information to other agencies and/or regulators. If you do not understand a statement, please ask a Debt Reduction Services (DRS) counselor for assistance.

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. (DRS) has put into place policies and procedures to protect the security and confidentiality of your nonpublic personal information. This notice explains our online information practices and how we use and maintain your information to conduct our financial education and credit counseling sessions and to fulfill information and question requests. This privacy policy complies with federal laws and regulations.

To provide our financial education and credit counseling services, we collect nonpublic personal information about you as follows: 1) Information we receive from you, 2) Information about your transactions with us or others, and 3) Information we receive from your creditors or a consumer reporting agency. We do not share this information with outside parties.

We use non-identifying and aggregate information to better design our website and services, but we do not disclose anything that could be used to identify you as an individual.

You hereby authorize DRS, when necessary, to share your nonpublic personal, financial, credit, and any information that you provided (including any computations and assessments produced) with the following entities in order to help DRS provide you with appropriate counseling or guide you to appropriate services: third parties such as government agencies, your lender(s), your creditor(s), and nonprofit housing-related and other financial agencies as permitted by law, including the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

To prevent unauthorized access, maintain data accuracy, and ensure the correct use of information, we have put in place appropriate physical, electronic, and managerial procedures to safeguard and secure the information we collect online. We limit access to your nonpublic personal information to our employees, contractors and agents who need such access to provide products or services to you or for other legitimate business purposes.

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. complies with the privacy requirements set forth in the HUD housing counseling agency handbook 7610.1 (05/2010), including the sections 2-2 Mc, 3-1 H(2), 3-3, 5-3 F, and Attachment A.5. At all times, we will comply with all additional laws and regulations to which we are subject regarding the collection, use, and disclosure of individually identifiable information.

  1. Services: DRS provides the following housing-related services: counseling that includes Homeless Assistance, Rental Topics, Pre-purchase/Homebuying, and Home Maintenance and Financial Management for Homeowners (Non-Delinquency Post-Purchase); Education courses that include Financial literacy (including home affordability, budgeting, and understanding use of credit), Predatory lending, loan scam or other fraud prevention, Fair housing, Rental topics, Pre-purchase homebuyer education, Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop (including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners), and other workshops not listed above.

Please refer to DebtReductionServices.org for details of our services.

  1. Limits: Our services are limited to our normal weekday business hours. We do not provide individual counseling or education services after hours or on weekends, although our education courses are available 24/7.
  2. Fees: We do not charge fees for our financial management counseling and education. However, if you use them, you may have to pay for our Debt Management Program, Student Loan Counseling, Bankruptcy Certificate Services or certain financial education courses (homebuyer education, rental topics, fair housing, predatory lending, and post-purchase-non-delinquency including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners).
  3. Records: We maintain records of the services you receive, including notes about your progress or other relevant information to your work with us. You have the right to access and view your records by making a request to your counselor.
  4. Confidentiality: We respect your privacy and offer our services in confidence with the understanding that we may share such information with auditors and government regulators. Certain laws or situations may also lead to disclosing confidential issues, such as those involving potential child abuse or neglect, threats to harm self or others, or court subpoenas.
  5. Refusal of Services: You have the right to refuse services without any penalty or loss.
  6. Disclosure of Policies and Practices: You will be provided our agency disclosure statement.
  7. Sharing of Information: Sometimes we will need to contact other agencies or we may need to share your information, including your records, with other agencies or with regulators. We will do this only if you sign this form that gives us permission except for limited reasons; please see # 5 above for examples of such situations.
  8. Other: You have the right to be treated with respect by our staff, and we expect the same from you in return. We encourage you to always ask questions if something is not clear. We also encouraged you to express your thoughts and advocate throughout our services.

You acknowledge that this authorization will remain in effect for the duration of time that DRS serves as your housing counselor or financial education provider. You also acknowledge that should you wish to terminate this authorization, you will notify DRS in writing.

Disclosure  Statement

NOTE: If you have an impairment, disability, language barrier, or otherwise require an alternative means of completing this form or accessing information about our counseling services, please communicate with your DRS representative about arranging alternative accommodations.

Program Disclosure Form

Disclosure to Client for HUD Housing Counseling Services

Debt Reduction Services, Inc. and its financial education arm, Money Fit by DRS, offer the following housing counseling and educational services related to housing, personal finance, and bankruptcy certificates to consumers:
  • Housing Education Courses: DRS offers many online self-guided education programs classified as Financial, Budgeting, and Credit Workshops (FBC), Fair Housing Pre-Purchase Education Workshops (FHW), Homelessness Prevention Workshops (HMW), Non-Delinquency Post Purchase Workshops (NDW), Predatory Lending Education Workshops (PLW), Pre-purchase Homebuyer Education Workshops (PPW), and Rental Housing Workshops (RHW). These courses help participants increase their knowledge of and skills in personal finance, including home affordability, budgeting, and understanding the use of credit, as well as predatory lending, loan scams, and other fraud prevention topics, fair housing, rental topics, pre-purchase homebuyer education, non-delinquency post-purchase topics including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners, homeless prevention workshop, and other workshops not listed above relating to personal finance and housing. Course details are found below under “Housing Workshops.”
  • Home Equity Conversation Mortgage (HECM) Counseling (RMC): Via telephone and virtual platforms, we offer the required HECM counseling nationwide in addition to in-person counseling in Boise, Idaho. We also offer in-home counseling options in thirty counties across southern Idaho for an additional fee to cover our travel and additional staff time costs.
  • Home Maintenance and Financial Management for Homeowners (Non-Delinquency Post-Purchase) (FBC): Clients receive counseling and materials on the proper maintenance of their home and mortgage refinancing. Clients can find help and resources by phone, in our Boise office, or virtually on all topics related to stabilizing their long-term homeownership.
  • Services for Homeless Counseling (HMC): Clients receive phone, virtual, or in-person (Boise) counseling to evaluate their current housing needs, identify barriers to and goals for housing stability, establish a path to self-sufficiency, and connect with emergency shelters, income-appropriate housing, and/or other community resources (e.g. mental healthcare, job training, transportation, etc.).
  • Pre-Purchase Counseling (PPC): Clients receive counseling through the entire homebuying process. Assistance may involve creating a sustainable household budget, understanding mortgage options, building their credit rating, and putting together a realistic action plan to set and achieve homeownership goals.  Additionally, clients will receive materials and resources about home inspections and other homeownership topics relevant to successfully maintaining a home.
  • Rental Housing Counseling (RHC): Via phone, in-person appointments (Boise, ID), or virtual platforms, clients receive housing counseling relevant to renting, including rent subsidies from HUD or other government and assistance programs. Topics can also address issues and concerns having to do with fair housing, landlord and tenant laws, lease terms, rent delinquency, household budgeting, and finding alternate housing.
DRS also offers the following services:
  • A Debt Management Program (DMP) for consumers struggling to pay their credit cards, collections, medical debts, personal loans, old utility bills, and past-due cell phone accounts;
  • The Budget Briefing and Debtor Education Certificates that are required during the Bankruptcy filing process;
  • A Student Loan Repayment Plan Counseling and application service.

Relationships with Industry Partners

Through such services, DRS has established financial relationships with hundreds of banks, credit unions, and creditors such as American Express, Bank of America, Barclays, Capital One, Chase, Citibank, Credit One, Discover, Synchrony, US Bank, USAA, Wells Fargo, and others.

No Client Obligation

The client is not obligated to receive, purchase or utilize any other services offered by DRS or its exclusive partners to receive financial education or housing counseling services. Alternatives: As a condition of our counseling services, in alignment with meeting our client services goals, and in compliance with HUD’s Housing Counseling Program requirements, we may provide information on alternative services, programs, and products available to you, if applicable and known by our staff. Alternative DMP services include negotiating better repayment terms directly with your individual creditors, paying your debts as agreed, or, in extreme cases, filing for personal bankruptcy. Alternative credit and education services can be found through MyMoney.gov or the Jump$tart Clearinghouse of online financial education resources. Housing counseling alternatives can be found through HUD at www.hud.gov/findacounselor.
Finally, you understand that you may revoke consent to these disclosures by notifying DRS in writing.

Housing Counseling and Education Fee Schedule

 

Online Education Program Fees*

Homebuyer Education Course: $59 per participant

  • Self-paced course available here, our online housing counseling and education center. Certificates will be automatically generated upon completion of the course (approximately 6-8 hours)

RentalFair HousingPredatory Lending / HOEPAPost-Purchase (Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop, including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners) Online Workshops: $49 per participant

  • Approximately 1 hour each

Other Self-Guided Financial Literacy Webinars (e.g. creditbudgetinghomeless preventiondebt prevention): $0

One-on-one Counseling Fees*

Pre-purchase Homebuying Counseling, Rental Counseling, Post-purchase Ownership Maintenance and Financial Management: $75

  • Session by the hour

Reverse Mortgage/HECM Counseling with Required Certificate:

  • $200†

Credit Report Fee: Paid Directly by Client

*Fees for all but our online education courses and workshops can be paid online by debit card, credit card, or PayPal or in person by cash, check or money order to: “Debt Reduction Services, Inc.” Registration fees are non-refundable 24 hours or less before the start of an in-person course or workshop. Certificates are non-transferable

*Fees may be waived for households with income of 150% or less of that identified on the US Department of Health and Human Services Poverty Guidelines Page

†Home visit counseling is available in 30 southern Idaho counties for potential HECM borrowers at additional costs to cover our travel (IRS reimbursement rates apply) and staff time ($50 per hour or fraction there).

Housing Counseling and Education Fee Schedule

 

Online Education Program Fees*

Homebuyer Education Course: $59 per participant

  • Self-paced course available here, our online housing counseling and education center. Certificates will be automatically generated upon completion of the course (approximately 6-8 hours)

RentalFair HousingPredatory Lending / HOEPAPost-Purchase (Non-delinquency post-purchase workshop, including home maintenance and/or financial management for homeowners) Online Workshops: $49 per participant

  • Approximately 1 hour each

Other Self-Guided Financial Literacy Webinars (e.g. creditbudgetinghomeless preventiondebt prevention): $0

One-on-one Counseling Fees*

Pre-purchase Homebuying Counseling, Rental Counseling, Post-purchase Ownership Maintenance and Financial Management: $75

  • Session by the hour

Reverse Mortgage/HECM Counseling with Required Certificate:

  • $200†

Credit Report Fee: Paid Directly by Client

*Fees for all but our online education courses and workshops can be paid online by debit card, credit card, or PayPal or in person by cash, check or money order to: “Debt Reduction Services, Inc.” Registration fees are non-refundable 24 hours or less before the start of an in-person course or workshop. Certificates are non-transferable

*Fees may be waived for households with income of 150% or less of that identified on the US Department of Health and Human Services Poverty Guidelines Page

†Home visit counseling is available in 30 southern Idaho counties for potential HECM borrowers at additional costs to cover our travel (IRS reimbursement rates apply) and staff time ($50 per hour or fraction there).